(02) 8806 0866 
Private, public and criminal law: conceptual distinctions
Criminal law is considered a type of public law, as it is concerned with offenses committed against society as a whole rather than just individuals. For example, murder, theft, and assault, are not just violations of an individual’s rights, but they are also considered to be a threat to the general public and the social order. The state, through its legal system, is responsible for prosecuting crimes and punishing those who are found guilty. Unlike civil law, which is concerned with disputes between private parties, the public authority represents the public interest and seeks to ensure that justice is served by prosecuting individuals who violate the law.
Examples of Public Functions
The function of criminal law is to protect society by regulating behaviour that is considered harmful, dangerous, or disruptive to the community. Criminal law achieves this by prohibiting and punishing conduct that is deemed to be criminal. Some of the key functions of criminal law are as follows:
- Deterrence: One of the primary functions of criminal law is to deter individuals from committing crimes. The prospect of being punished for criminal behaviour is intended to discourage individuals from engaging in such conduct.
- Retribution: Criminal law serves to punish offenders for their criminal behaviour. The punishment is typically proportionate to the seriousness of the offense committed and is intended to hold offenders accountable for their actions.
- Rehabilitation: Criminal law also aims to rehabilitate offenders and to help them become law-abiding members of society. This can involve providing treatment for drug addiction or mental health issues, or providing education and job training to help offenders reintegrate into society.
- Protection: Criminal law also serves to protect society by removing dangerous or violent offenders from the community. Imprisonment, for example, is intended to protect society from individuals who pose a threat to public safety.
- Restoration: Criminal law can also serve to restore the harm caused by criminal conduct. For example, restitution orders can be imposed to compensate victims of crime for their losses, and community service can be ordered to help offenders make amends for their wrongdoing.
Private law and criminal law
Private and criminal law are two distinct branches of law that serve different purposes.
Private law applies to the relationships between private individuals or entities, such as contract law, property law, tax law, competition law and family law matters. Private law is concerned with resolving disputes between private parties, and the goal is to provide a fair and equitable resolution that is enforceable by law.
Criminal law, on the other hand, is concerned with criminal offence committed against society as a whole, rather than just individuals. Criminal law prohibits and punishes conduct that is considered harmful or disruptive to the community, such as murder, theft, and assault. Criminal cases are typically brought by the state or government, and the goal is to protect society by punishing offenders and deterring others from engaging in similar behaviour.
Overlap between criminal law and private law
While private law and criminal law are distinct branches of law, they can sometimes overlap in certain circumstances. For example:
- Criminal acts can also give rise to civil liability: When a person commits a criminal act, such as assault or theft, they can also be held civilly liable for the same conduct. In such cases, the victim of the crime can pursue a civil action against the perpetrator for damages, such as medical expenses, lost wages, or emotional distress.
- Criminal law can be used to enforce private rights: Sometimes, criminal law can be used to enforce private rights. For example, a person who violates a court order, such as a restraining order, can be charged with a criminal offense for contempt of court. Similarly, a person who commits fraud or breaches a contract can be charged with a criminal offense for theft or fraud.
- Criminal law can impact private law cases: In some cases, a criminal conviction can have an impact on a civil case. For example, a person who is convicted of a crime may be prohibited from bringing a civil claim for damages arising from the same conduct. Additionally, the criminal conviction can be used as evidence in a civil case to establish liability.
- Private law can impact criminal law cases: Private law can also have an impact on criminal law cases. For example, a person who is sued civilly for damages arising from a criminal offense may choose to plead the Fifth Amendment in the civil case to avoid self-incrimination in the criminal case.
2 What is the Difference Between Public Law and Private Law?
Public law and private law are two broad categories of legal systems that govern different aspects of society.
Public law
Public law is concerned with the relationship between the government and its citizens, as well as the relationship between different branches of government. Public law includes constitutional law, administrative law, and criminal law. Constitutional law establishes the fundamental principles and framework of government, while administrative law governs the actions and decisions of government agencies. Criminal law prohibits and punishes conduct that is considered harmful or disruptive to the community.
Private law
Private law, also known as civil law, is concerned with the relationship between private individuals or entities. Private law includes contract law, property law, and tort law. Contract law governs the formation and enforcement of agreements between individuals or entities, while property law regulates the ownership and use of property. Tort law deals with civil wrongs or injuries, such as negligence or intentional harm.
What is the Difference Between Public Law and Private Law?
Subject matter
The main difference between public law and private law is the subject matter they govern. Public law regulates the relationship between the government and its citizens, while private law governs the relationships between private individuals or entities. Public law is concerned with protecting the public interest and maintaining the rule of law, while private law is concerned with protecting individual rights and interests.
Source of law
Another important difference is the source of law. Public law is created by the government, through legislation, regulations, and judicial decisions. Private law, on the other hand, is primarily created through contracts, common law, and other private arrangements.
In summary, public law and private law are distinct legal systems that serve different purposes and govern different aspects of society. While there may be some overlap between the two, the main difference lies in the subject matter they regulate and the source of law.
