Criminal law is a complex area of law and legal advice should be sought at the first opportunity. There are many different aspects of criminal law and criminal offences can be categorized according to whether they are violent, civil, etc.
Below we will discuss some different examples of criminal offences and how criminal law applies to those scenarios. We will also be considering how criminal law and civil law intertwine and what the difference between civil and criminal law is with demonstrative examples.
The most critical advice you could receive however is to seek legal advice early. It will lower your stress, ensure a smoother process and by all accounts demonstrate to the court that you are taking the matter seriously.
What Is Criminal Law?
Criminal law is the foundation for the criminal justice system and it underpins the process of determining a guilty or not guilty verdict. The criminal justice system is designed to protect society and courts create a sense of security for the general community.
There can be several different pieces of legislation to consider depending on the circumstances of the charge and it is important to seek advice from an expert in the field to ensure no mistakes are made with interpretation. All criminal law offences are subject to the Criminal Code specific to each individual state and territory however there are other acts such as the Drug Misuse Act or Traffic offences legislation which may need to be considered in conjunction with the criminal code act.
You should never attempt to interpret legislation without the assistance of expert legal advice. Interpretation is key when determining legislation and a wrong interpretation could be the difference between a guilty and not guilty verdict.
Legislation will contain a breakdown of the elements required to prove a specific criminal charge, a definition of what constitutes each specific act as well as an indication of whether there are any maximum or minimum sentences. This creates a somewhat universal punishment system for the courts to rely on but there is discretion for Magistrate’s and judges depending on the circumstances. There is also the option to mix and match sentences and order more than one type of sentence.
Traffic Offenses
A core area of criminal law is traffic offences. These types of criminal offenses relate to illegal conduct committed whilst operating a motor vehicle or motorbike. This includes drink driving, speeding, driving under the influence of illicit drugs, etc.
Traffic offenses are heard in either the District court or Supreme court depending on the severity of the charge. The district court hears summary offences while the Supreme Court hears indictable offences.
These offences are simply one aspect of criminal law however it is the aspect that most people are familiar with. You can commit a traffic offence without ever having the matter taken to court.
Case Study
This is because the police file has been received and there is significant evidence to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Helena is guilty. She is concerned that she is currently involved in family court proceedings with her ex husband and that this could prevent her from seeing her children. Child custody disputes are messy and her ex husband has already used her criminal history against her.
She pleads guilty to the charges and receives a 2 year suspended sentence. She further has her licence disqualified for that period.
What Sentences Can I Be Subject To?
- Monetary Penalty;
- Suspended Sentence;
- Term of Imprisonment;
- Community Corrections Order.
How Is A Criminal Offence Prosecuted?
Criminal prosecution of a criminal act is subject to the a court process in either the supreme or district court. It is the responsibility of the prosecution to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty.
It is the responsibility of the defence to refute the prosecution’s evidence and damage its credibility. If there is doubt then the prosecution have not made their case and a guilty verdict cannot be proven.
If your matter is heard in the supreme court then it is classed as an indictable offence and will be subject to a trial by judge and jury. If your matter is heard in the district court then it is classed as a summary offence and will be subject to an independent judicial officer or Magistrate.
Case Study
Anton has been charged with domestic violence offences against his wife as well as sexual assault and is in need of a good criminal lawyer. Anton has never been charged with an offence before but he is concerned that the charged against him are significant. Anton claims that he and his wife got into a heated argument and that he needed to defend himself when it became violent.
He is hoping his lawyers can prevent prosecution from commencing proceedings against him. He has read of other criminal cases of a similar nature and he does not want to see the inside of the court room. Given the evidence, he is afraid that the evidence will be against him. He is also at risk of the court ordering costs against him if he is found guilty.
What Is The Difference Between Civil Law and Criminal Law?
The main difference between criminal law and civil law is that civil law involves disputes that are subject to a lower standard of proof. Specifically, civil law is measured against a balance of probabilities whereas criminal law is measured beyond a reasonable doubt. Criminal law offences are heard in a higher court to that of civil law offences.
Criminal law cases have a higher standard of proof as they are usually a more serious aspect of law but they carry more serious penalties. Typically, civil law involves monetary compensation as a punishment instead of a term of imprisonment however different circumstances are taken into account.
Civil cases require the individual bringing the dispute to bear the onus of proof which is not unlike criminal law. in this regard. The accused person never bears the onus of proof. However, civil proceedings may result in the losing party paying the winning party’s legal costs which is unlike criminal law. This is a process designed to deter people from making claims which hold little merit or evidence.
Civil Law Cases
Civil law, or tort law, is heard in a civil court room instead of a criminal court room. Civil claim disputes are subject to torts and negligence law and are not held to the same standard as criminal claims.
Civil cases still require the same process as criminal law cases. Persuasive authority is needed, the judge is required to hear evidence and determine the weight and merit to be attached and state law (civil laws) still needs to be applied. The evidence is then considered against the balance of probabilities to determine an outcome.
Civil law cases can involve criminal law proceedings however as civil offending can lead to criminal charges depending on the circumstances. If a criminal case arises from a civil claim it is because the action of the individual also breached a section of the criminal code or other legislation.
Case Study
The criminal acts he is accused of committing could become federal law offences and there is a concern that federal criminal charges can result in severe sentences and terms of imprisonment.
The civil law aspect however is more clear cut and Marcus's lawyers are confident there is case law to help them achieve a not guilty verdict. Marcus has been accused of unlawful interference with with bankruptcy proceedings for some of his clients. He has been profiting off his clients by taking bribes. Not only is this an offence but it is a corporate crime, or white collar crime.
Marcus loses his licence to legally represent clients in bankruptcy hearings. The civil proceedings will ultimately have influence over the criminal proceedings. A separate claim has now been filed against Marcus to pay the legal costs of the company he worked for as he was the losing party.
Common Law
Common law refers to the laws created which form case law. It is a historical consideration of law that is derived from Roman law. Common law is commonly referred to as either case law or statute law and it is a critical aspect of all legal principles.
Statute law and case law is a relevant consideration of criminal law and civil law as precedent cases are applied when determining both guilt and sentencing. Courts will adopt the principles from cases which have come before when determining the factors of present cases. An accused person should be aware of this and take advice from their lawyer appropriately.
In a nutshell...
Civil and criminal law can be linked depending on the type of offending that occurs. Criminal law deals with an individual unlawfully breaking the law and creating a risk or harm or danger as a result. Civil law however refers to a civil claim that is brought by companies or individuals against another individual.
The difference between civil and criminal law is the standard of proof that exists for a guilty verdict. Criminal law is held to a much higher standard and the prosecution bears the burden of proof for a criminal case. Civil claims however, are more reliant on common law principles and the balance of probabilities.
No matter whether you have been charged with a criminal law or civil law offence you should seek advice immediately from an expert lawyer. Jameson Law are able to assist with all matters involving both civil and criminal law and will be able to assist you no matter whether your matter is being heard in a lower court or higher court.
If you remember nothing else the following three points are key;
- Early legal advice is best;
- Never try to interpret legislation alone; and
- Evidence speaks volumes.