Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) is a range of processes that help parties resolve disputes outside of judicial determination in the criminal justice context. ADR includes mediation, conciliation and arbitration, where an impartial or independent third person helps parties resolve disputes.
Restorative justice is closely associated with ADR and seeks solutions beyond the traditional disciplinary model. See NSW guidance on restorative practices via NSW Communities and Justice and national policy from the Attorney-General’s Department.
ADR is used to divert offenders away from court proceedings, allow community involvement and give victims an active role. For an overview of court pathways, see criminal law in NSW and court procedures.
The goals of ADR in the criminal context include diversion from contested hearings, meaningful participation by victims and stronger community outcomes. The concept is relatively recent in Australia’s otherwise adversarial system, which has emphasised punishment and deterrence. Over recent decades, jurisdictions have adopted ADR to address causes of offending and victim impact. Research from the Australian Institute of Criminology and state agencies continues to inform best practice.
The use of ADR reflects a shift towards restorative justice principles that prioritise healing, restitution and community involvement. For tailored advice about your matter, contact our Sydney criminal lawyers.
Speak to a lawyer today
This evolution aims to reduce recidivism, ease court backlogs and deliver more meaningful resolutions for victims and offenders. If you need guidance now, contact Jameson Law or call (02) 8806 0866.
Types of ADR in Criminal Law
Several forms of ADR are utilised within the Australian criminal justice system:
Restorative Justice Conferences. Facilitated meetings between the offender, the victim and supporters to discuss harm and agree on steps to make amends. Common in youth justice and increasingly explored in more serious matters. See Youth Justice NSW and ALRC materials for policy context.
Diversion Programs. Alternatives to formal charges or hearings, often for first-time or lower-risk offenders. Measures may include community service, counselling or rehabilitation, or participation in conferencing. Ask our team about diversion pathways and local program availability.
Mediation. A neutral mediator helps the victim and offender negotiate practical outcomes such as apologies or restitution. Mediation is less formal and can align with defence strategy and sentencing goals.
Plea Bargaining. Negotiations between prosecution and defence to resolve charges or facts without a full trial. While not strictly ADR, it functions as an alternative to a contested hearing. See our overview of common charges and how resolutions are reached.
Benefits of ADR in Criminal Law
Victim Empowerment. Restorative processes centre the victim’s voice. Victims can express harm, ask questions and participate in outcomes. Support is available through Victims Services NSW.
Offender Rehabilitation. By addressing causes of offending and fostering accountability, ADR supports behaviour change and can reduce reoffending.
Cost and Time Efficiency. Appropriate diversion frees court resources and reduces delay. More on timelines: NSW court procedures.
Community Engagement. Community participation in conferences can rebuild trust and promote social cohesion.
Challenges and Criticisms
Suitability for Serious Offences. Care is needed where power imbalances exist. Participation must be voluntary and safe.
Legal Protections. ADR is less formal, so safeguards around consent, fairness and oversight are essential.
Inconsistent Application. Programs vary across states and territories. Our team can explain local settings and eligibility.
Perception of Leniency. Some view diversion as too light. Clear outcomes, compliance checks and judicial oversight help maintain public confidence.
Future Directions
Expanding Restorative Practice. Ongoing pilots examine use in domestic violence and other serious offences with strict safeguards.
Digital ADR. Video-based mediation and online conferences now supplement in-person sessions where appropriate.
Cultural Appropriateness. Greater focus on culturally safe processes for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and other communities.
Restorative Justice in the Australian System
Restorative justice brings together those affected by an offence to decide how to address harm and prevent recurrence. In Australia, ADR in youth justice includes conferencing, circle sentencing and victim–offender mediation. Studies indicate restorative interventions can reduce reoffending and deliver high satisfaction for victims. For case-specific advice, speak with our criminal defence solicitors.
In a nutshell…
ADR in criminal law is a dynamic, evolving field. While there are challenges, the benefits for victims, offenders and communities make it a compelling alternative in suitable cases. For guidance on whether ADR or restorative options apply to your matter, contact Jameson Law or call (02) 8806 0866.
